| Typical Chemical Composition | Iron-based alloy with approximately 0.25–0.29% carbon, plus manganese and small amounts of silicon, phosphorus, and sulfur. Exact limits depend on the applicable standard. | Approximately 18% chromium and 8% nickel, with iron as the balance. Low-carbon variants such as 304L are commonly selected for improved weld corrosion resistance. | Aluminum alloy containing approximately 0.8–1.2% magnesium and 0.4–0.8% silicon, with smaller amounts of iron, copper, manganese, chromium, zinc, and titanium. |
| Density | Approximately 7.85 g/cm³ | Approximately 8.00 g/cm³ | Approximately 2.70 g/cm³ |
| Typical Yield Strength | About 250 MPa minimum for ASTM A36 plate and structural shapes. | About 205 MPa minimum for annealed AISI 304, depending on product form and specification. | About 240 MPa minimum for AA 6061-T6 sheet or plate, depending on thickness and product standard. |
| Typical Tensile Strength | Approximately 400–550 MPa for ASTM A36 products. | Approximately 515 MPa minimum for annealed AISI 304, with actual values varying by product form. | Approximately 290 MPa minimum for AA 6061-T6, depending on thickness and specification. |
| Weldability | Generally excellent for low-carbon grades. Preheating is usually unnecessary for thin sections but may be required for thicker or highly restrained joints. | Good weldability. Heat input and interpass temperature should be controlled to limit distortion, discoloration, and corrosion-related issues. | Good weldability with suitable equipment and filler metal. The oxide layer must be removed or controlled, and heat management is important because aluminum conducts heat rapidly. |
| Recommended Welding Processes | GMAW/MIG, FCAW, SMAW, and SAW are widely used. Process selection depends on thickness, joint design, productivity, and site conditions. | GTAW/TIG for precision and appearance; GMAW/MIG, pulsed MIG, and FCAW for higher productivity. Shielding gas purity is important. | GTAW/TIG and GMAW/MIG, including pulsed MIG. AC TIG is commonly used for cleaning action on suitable applications. |
| Common Filler Metal Options | ER70S-series wire for MIG/TIG and E7018-type low-hydrogen electrodes for stick welding are common choices when compatible with the base metal and service requirements. | ER308L is commonly used for 304/304L joints. Filler selection should consider corrosion environment, dilution, and service temperature. | ER4043 is often selected for general-purpose welding and reduced distortion risk; ER5356 may provide higher strength and better color matching for certain applications. |
| Corrosion Resistance | Low to moderate in unprotected outdoor or humid environments. Painting, galvanizing, coating, or other corrosion protection is normally required. | High resistance to atmospheric corrosion and many industrial environments. Chloride exposure can cause localized pitting or stress-corrosion concerns under certain conditions. | Good natural corrosion resistance due to its oxide film. Galvanic corrosion can occur when aluminum contacts dissimilar metals in the presence of an electrolyte. |
| Thermal Conductivity | Approximately 45–60 W/m·K, depending on grade and temperature. | Approximately 14–16 W/m·K at room temperature. | Approximately 160–235 W/m·K, depending on alloy and temper. |
| Thermal Expansion | Approximately 11–13 × 10−6/K | Approximately 17–18 × 10−6/K | Approximately 23–24 × 10−6/K |
| Weight Efficiency | Lowest weight efficiency among the three materials because of its high density, but it offers strong structural value and broad availability. | Heavier than aluminum and generally similar in density to carbon steel, but offers strong corrosion resistance and long service life. | About one-third the density of steel, making it advantageous when total component weight, transport cost, or handling efficiency is important. |
| Heat-Affected Zone Considerations | Low-carbon grades generally retain practical weldability, but hydrogen cracking, residual stress, and hardening risks increase with carbon equivalent and thickness. | The heat-affected zone may experience distortion and sensitization concerns in some conditions. Low-carbon grades and controlled heat input can reduce intergranular corrosion risk. | Heat from welding reduces the original T6 temper near the joint, so local post-weld strength may be lower unless an appropriate design or heat treatment is used. |
| Fabrication and Machining | Easy to cut, form, drill, and repair. Surface preparation and removal of mill scale, oil, and rust are important before welding. | Good formability and weldability, but work hardening can make machining more demanding. Dedicated stainless tools help prevent iron contamination. | Easy to form and machine, but its softness and high thermal conductivity require suitable cutting parameters and clean joint preparation. |
| Typical Global Applications | Structural frames, machinery bases, platforms, brackets, general fabrication, storage structures, agricultural equipment, and transport infrastructure. | Food-processing equipment, architectural fabrication, chemical-processing components, medical and sanitary equipment, kitchen equipment, and outdoor assemblies. | Lightweight frames, transport equipment, marine components, heat exchangers, pressureless enclosures, architectural structures, and portable equipment. |
| Best Selection Advantage | Cost-effective structural performance, easy sourcing, broad welding process compatibility, and straightforward repairability. | Excellent balance of weldability, appearance, hygiene, and corrosion resistance for demanding service environments. | Low weight, good corrosion resistance, high thermal conductivity, and strong suitability for weight-sensitive designs. |
| Main Purchasing Risks | Unexpected corrosion, inconsistent surface condition, inadequate weld consumable storage, and insufficient control of preheat or hydrogen for thick sections. | Incorrect grade selection, surface contamination, excessive heat input, chloride exposure, and loss of corrosion performance near improperly finished welds. | Porosity, oxide inclusions, distortion, incorrect filler selection, galvanic corrosion, and overestimating post-weld strength in heat-treated alloys. |
| Recommended Quality Documents | Mill test certificate, material grade and heat number, dimensional inspection report, welding procedure specification, and coating or surface-treatment records when applicable. | Mill test certificate, chemical composition report, corrosion or surface-finish requirements, welding procedure specification, and passivation or pickling records when required. | Mill test certificate, alloy and temper verification, dimensional report, filler metal certificate, welding procedure specification, and heat-treatment or temper records. |
| Best Fit for Global Projects | Projects prioritizing structural strength, procurement flexibility, repairability, and competitive material cost. | Projects requiring durable welded assemblies in corrosive, hygienic, decorative, or low-maintenance environments. | Projects prioritizing low mass, transport efficiency, corrosion resistance, and high heat dissipation. |
| Technical note: Values are typical reference ranges for representative grades and are not a substitute for the applicable ASTM, EN, ISO, or other project specification. Final material selection should consider joint design, thickness, service temperature, corrosion environment, required mechanical properties, welding procedure qualification, filler compatibility, and local regulatory requirements. |